Once you’ve established the criteria for identifying a top-tier SEO company, it’s time to begin researching potential agencies. Based on our analysis, businesses commonly explore several avenues to discover reputable SEO agencies, including:

• Referrals
• Online search
• Social media
• Industry conferences or events

Referrals serve as an excellent starting point, often connecting you with high-quality SEO agencies that have earned the trust of their clients.

If referrals do not yield satisfactory results, proceed to conduct an online search.

When conducting online searches for an SEO company, it’s essential to refine your search criteria effectively.

For instance, if your priority is to secure the services of a reputable SEO company at a competitive price point, avoid generic searches for “cheap SEO agencies,” as these may lead to subpar providers offering services at low rates, which may not align with your requirements for quality and reliability.

Typically, your search results will include listings from third-party review platforms and the official websites of SEO agencies. Armed with the insights gained from our earlier guidelines on identifying a reputable SEO company, you can streamline your list of potential firms and proceed to evaluate them using the following steps.

Case studies serve as valuable resources in the selection process of an SEO company.

When assessing case studies provided by a search engine optimization firm, pay attention to the following elements:

• Objectives: Determine the goals set by both the client and the agency.
• Metrics: Analyze the metrics used to gauge performance and ascertain if they align with the client’s objectives.
• Timeframe: Evaluate the duration of the campaign and the timeframe used to measure progress.
• Testimonials: Consider the client’s feedback and their overall experience with the agency.

To delve deeper into case studies, consider taking additional steps such as:

• Validating the existence of the featured client.
• Scrutinizing the featured client’s website using tools like Screaming Frog.

These additional measures can help verify the authenticity and credibility of the case study. If you received a referral to the SEO agency, the recommendation from a trusted source can provide sufficient validation of the agency’s work and its case studies.

Overall, thorough research will provide insights into:

• The agency’s flexibility in meeting client requirements versus utilizing standardized SEO strategies.
• The agency’s approach to measuring success, whether focusing on revenue or rankings.
• The execution process of the agency’s SEO strategies.
• The types of companies the agency typically collaborates with, such as business-to-business (B2B) enterprises.

This comprehensive understanding will aid in determining if the agency is the right fit for your SEO needs.

Dedicate some time to reviewing client feedback across various platforms, including:

• Google Business Profile
• Third-party review platforms like Clutch
• Bing Places
• Social media platforms such as Facebook

While scrutinizing online reviews, ponder over the following inquiries:

• Are the reviews detailed and insightful, or do they appear generic?
• What is the distribution of positive, neutral, and negative reviews?
• What recurring themes emerge in the positive and negative feedback?
• How does the agency respond to reviews (if applicable), and what is the nature of their responses?

Additionally, consider the factors that other businesses prioritize when selecting an SEO company, such as:

• Overall Reputation
• Pricing structure
• Industry-specific reputation
• Years of experience and specialized expertise
• Quality of customer service
• Success in achieving SEO rankings

It’s worth noting that while many businesses emphasize factors like reputation, pricing, and experience, they often overlook the significance of customer service. Hence, pay attention to remarks regarding customer service aspects such as responsiveness, communication, and reporting when perusing client reviews.

By delving into client reviews, you can gain insights into:

• Areas of excellence exhibited by the agency
• Potential areas for improvement or shortcomings
• How the agency addresses and responds to feedback

Once you’ve extracted key takeaways from the reviews, evaluate them through the lens of your company’s specific needs and priorities. For instance, if your organization places a high value on comprehensive reporting and an agency consistently receives praise for its reporting practices, it may warrant further consideration. Conversely, if an agency gets frequent complaints about reporting deficiencies, it may not align with your company’s requirements.

When you begin conversations with past or present clients, you’re nearing the final stages of selecting an SEO company.

To implement this step in your quest to find an SEO company, you’ll need to initiate contact with the agency. Typically, SEO agencies prefer to discuss with your team before disclosing their client roster. These dialogues serve to gauge compatibility between your respective entities.

Should there be mutual alignment between your organization and the SEO agency, they’ll furnish you with a client roster upon request.

Upon receipt of the client list, it’s prudent to heed the advice of Shirey, who suggests, “Ensure that you reach out to perhaps three to five existing clients of the SEO provider for vetting. Inquire about their satisfaction levels in dealing with the specific company.”

Here are some additional queries you might consider posing:

• How long have you been collaborating with this SEO agency?
• What were your initial objectives upon enlisting the services of the SEO agency, and have you realized them?
• What is the typical responsiveness of the agency in returning your calls or emails?
• How substantial is the time commitment required from your end when partnering with the agency?
• Can you identify an aspect in which the SEO firm could enhance its services?
• Would you recommend this agency? If so, what are the primary reasons for your recommendation?

If the SEO agency declines to furnish a client roster or fails to provide a minimum of three to five current clients for reference, it may warrant reconsideration in your decision-making process. Such reluctance could signify a lack of enthusiastic endorsements from satisfied clientele or an insufficient client base.

Deliverables serve as invaluable tools when evaluating SEO agencies as they outline the specifics of what, when, and how SEO services will be provided. Through these deliverables, you gain insight into the tasks the agency will undertake, their timeline for completion, and associated costs.

While many SEO firms do not openly disclose their service deliverables online (with Stratedia being an exception), you’ll need to reach out to these agencies directly to obtain this information. Typically, agencies prefer to engage in preliminary discussions with potential clients to ascertain mutual compatibility before sharing their deliverables.

Upon receiving the deliverables, ensure they encompass the following key components:

1. SEO audit
2. Keyword research
3. On-page optimizations
4. Off-page optimizations
5. Technical optimizations
6. Regular reporting
7. Designated point of contact

If you’ve engaged in discussions with the agency, scrutinize the deliverables to ascertain if they align with the specific needs discussed. While not mandatory, the inclusion of bespoke elements tailored to your requirements reflects the agency’s attentiveness to your SEO objectives and commitment to fostering a collaborative partnership with your business.

The concluding phase of selecting an SEO company entails engaging with your prospective agencies.

Before committing to an SEO agency, it’s imperative to schedule a meeting with them. Whether conducted in person or virtually, such as via video conference, this direct interaction provides an opportunity for your team to assess the compatibility of the agency with your requirements and objectives.

Examples of inquiries you can pose include:

• How much involvement will be required from my business?
• What is the expected timeline for seeing results?
• What level of experience do you possess in our industry?
• Can you provide details on the cost of your services?
• How do you implement SEO strategies?

For an effective meeting, collaborate with your team and organizational leaders to generate a range of questions. While your team may be interested in aspects like strategy and reporting, decision-makers may prioritize inquiries regarding pricing and return on investment (ROI).

Additionally, ensure that you feel at ease with the agency. It’s crucial to have a sense of comfort in asking questions, expressing concerns, and more. Without this comfort level, establishing a long-term partnership, essential for SEO’s ongoing and lasting impact, may prove challenging.

Particularly for smaller companies, the inability to achieve desired results internally serves as the main driver for seeking external assistance with their SEO endeavors.

Given this reliance on external expertise, thorough research becomes paramount when selecting an SEO company.

Businesses require access to comprehensive tools for scrutinizing potential SEO service providers, enabling them to validate the agency’s proficiency. Factors such as case studies, reviews, accolades, and client testimonials serve as crucial resources in guiding businesses toward identifying the most suitable SEO company to fulfill their requirements.

The primary avenue through which companies connect with an SEO agency is through referrals.

From recommendations by friends and colleagues to insights from sales and marketing professionals within their network, referrals serve as the preferred method for sourcing potential SEO partners. However, in cases where referrals fall short, companies resort to utilizing search engines to explore the expertise and capabilities of various SEO service providers.

While direct outreach can be an effective sales strategy, it is met with mixed reactions due to certain drawbacks. These include the employment of aggressive sales tactics, such as promoting limited-time offers, overpromising quick results like achieving page-one rankings within a short timeframe, and exhibiting limited transparency regarding pricing and service deliverables.

Recognizing the significance of informed decision-making in selecting an SEO company, we underscored the importance of education. Businesses need to equip themselves with knowledge about the characteristics of reputable and trustworthy agencies to effectively evaluate firms and navigate direct outreach offers.

Businesses consider various factors when selecting an SEO agency, prioritizing them from most to least important:

1. Overall reputation
2. Price
3. Reputation within a specific industry
4. Experience and expertise
5. Customer service
6. SEO rankings

Interestingly, enterprise-level companies ranked SEO costs as the top priority, followed closely by reputation.

Given these insights, it’s evident that companies need to undertake certain steps before finalizing their choice of an SEO agency:

1. Familiarize themselves with the criteria for assessing the reputation of an SEO company.
2. Gain knowledge about the typical costs associated with SEO services.
3. Understand the advantages of forging a long-term partnership with an SEO agency compared to opting for short-term solutions.

Companies expressed satisfaction with their SEO providers, with 46% indicating a willingness to recommend their SEO partner.

As part of our survey, businesses assessed their satisfaction levels using the Net Promoter Score (NPS). The majority of respondents rated as Promoters, indicating they would recommend their SEO provider to others. However, 53.8% fell into the categories of Detractors (dissatisfied) or Passives (neutral).

This data highlighted that although most companies were not dissatisfied with their SEO providers, a significant portion were not enthusiastic about recommending them. This is noteworthy as recommendations play a crucial role in how businesses typically choose an SEO company.

Once again, we recognized the importance of education in assisting businesses in evaluating SEO agencies and identifying the most suitable SEO provider. Additionally, there was an opportunity for companies to reconsider their criteria for selecting an SEO services provider, particularly in prioritizing customer service, which could have a significant impact on their overall experience and satisfaction.

Every business, regardless of its success, can fall prey to mistakes. That’s why, prior to embarking on the journey of selecting an SEO company, it’s crucial to examine the prevalent errors frequently encountered by organizations in their quest for an SEO agency.

These three missteps encompass:

When it comes to SEO services and selecting the right agency, pricing is undoubtedly a crucial factor. Establishing a budget for SEO and identifying a company that fits within that budget is essential. However, a common mistake made by many businesses is setting unrealistic budget expectations.

Upon encountering agencies offering SEO services for as low as $100 per month, some businesses may perceive this as a reasonable investment. However, the reality is quite different. Agencies promoting such ultra-low rates often fail to deliver on their promises.

They may lack in crafting a comprehensive strategy tailored to your specific needs, resorting instead to generic approaches that yield minimal to no results. Furthermore, inadequate communication with your team can lead to a subpar customer experience and minimal returns on investment.

In more severe cases, these agencies may resort to employing black-hat SEO techniques, risking potential penalties from search engines like Google.

In the realm of SEO, quality often aligns with pricing. Thus, it’s imperative to educate your company about the realistic costs associated with SEO services. By doing so, you can establish a feasible monthly budget that reflects the true value of effective SEO strategies. On average, businesses allocate between $2500 to $7500 per month for SEO endeavors, although this figure may vary depending on various factors such as strategy intricacy and company size.

While engaging a local SEO agency can offer certain advantages, such as easier collaboration and potentially better understanding of local markets, solely focusing on local options may limit your choices and hinder your SEO success.

When evaluating SEO companies, it’s crucial to prioritize factors like experience, performance track record, and client satisfaction over geographical proximity. These aspects have a more significant impact on the quality of service you’ll receive.

By solely considering local agencies, you might overlook highly experienced firms located elsewhere. This could result in missed opportunities for achieving desired search engine rankings and tapping into valuable organic traffic streams.

For instance, if a competitor partners with a reputable agency located in another state while you settle for a local but less experienced firm, it could put your business at a disadvantage in terms of online visibility and lead generation.

Even if you opt for a non-local SEO company, many such firms endeavor to bridge the geographical gap. They may arrange occasional in-person meetings, utilize video conferencing, or conduct regular phone calls to maintain a close and personal relationship with your team. Thus, geographical distance should not be a deterrent in selecting the most suitable SEO partner for your business.

While businesses understandably seek prompt results from their SEO efforts, it’s important to recognize that genuine SEO success typically takes time—often three to six months or more.

This delay can lead to frustration, prompting some savvy companies to consider black-hat SEO techniques. Black-hat SEO encompasses unethical and ultimately ineffective long-term strategies. Although these tactics may yield quick results in terms of search engine rankings, they come with significant risks.

Employing black hat methods can result in rapid ranking declines and, in severe cases, outright bans from search engine results pages, particularly from Google. Such penalties severely impact a website’s visibility, hindering its ability to attract organic traffic and potential customers.

To avoid these detrimental consequences, it’s crucial to prioritize established, white-hat SEO agencies. These firms adhere to industry best practices and ethical strategies, ensuring sustainable and legitimate growth in search engine rankings.

It’s worth noting that low-cost SEO services and black-hat SEO practices often go hand-in-hand. Therefore, investing in reputable, white-hat SEO services is essential for safeguarding your website’s long-term success and reputation.

Interested in delving deeper into the process of selecting the ideal SEO company?

Subscribe to Stratedia for valuable insights, practical tips, and expert strategies delivered straight to your inbox. It’s completely free, incredibly insightful, and it will streamline your quest for the right online marketing agency.